Geez3r Posted August 26, 2008 Posted August 26, 2008 I've got 2 questions for Immunity to Will saves 1) Person A has Immunity to Will saves and is attacked by Person B who has Mental Blast with the No Saving throw extra. Who trumps who? I believe Person A suffers no ill effects of the attack. 2) Person B tries to Intimidate Person A. Can Person A oppose Person B with his Will save and there by be immune? A question on Mental Blast 1) Person A has Mind Blast, and uses it on Person B who having a +4 bonus to Will saves, fails by 3 and takes a bruise. On the next round Person A Mind Blasts Person B again, but Person B still uses his whole +4 bonus again because that bruise does not affect his Will save. Is this correct?
Dr Archeville Posted August 27, 2008 Posted August 27, 2008 1) Person A has Immunity to Will saves and is attacked by Person B who has Mental Blast with the No Saving throw extra. Who trumps who? I believe Person A suffers no ill effects of the attack. Under the description of the No Save extra in UP, it says Immunity trumps No SAve powers. 2) Person B tries to Intimidate Person A. Can Person A oppose Person B with his Will save and there by be immune? I... am not sure. 1) Person A has Mind Blast, and uses it on Person B who having a +4 bonus to Will saves, fails by 3 and takes a bruise. On the next round Person A Mind Blasts Person B again, but Person B still uses his whole +4 bonus again because that bruise does not affect his Will save. Is this correct? Strictly by the rules, yes, since bruises & so on impose a penalty on the Toughness save against further damage. However, I could see a case for a house rule where damage from non-Toughness save effects (like Mental Blast or an Alt Save/Fortitude Damage effect) could impose a similar penalty on that type of save, at least in regards to Damage effects calling for that save.
N/A Posted September 12, 2008 Posted September 12, 2008 According to this and this, Bruises/Injuries from Damage effects do indeed cause a penalty to all further Damage saves, regardless of which type of save they provoke.
Recommended Posts